Brilliant interview. We hosted him in Chicago last year, he is such a humble soul, comes across a genuine person. Pakistan, and Sindh in particular, needs a leader like him.
Just wow. It felt so good listening to JZAB. Indeed, he is a hope for the poor people of not only Sindh but also of all Pakistan. Thanks to red room for inviting him.
The guy reveals his brains finally. The real ones should be in their place. But the challenge would emmensely tough because of the other side; who are Islamists beyond his personal rivalries.
You guys forgot bhutto started with progressive ideas and after coming to power within 3 years coming to power he changed also with the time and changed the way he wanted to govern he started listening to religious groups and change the original ppp agenda don't blame benazir.
Mashallah AP k sessions both informative ha. Meri family b AP ka program bohat dekhti ha and included me ma b bachpan sa AP ki story PTV per dekhta tha.lakin ab internet mobile per convert ho gia. Mashallah may Allah bless you always. One more thing 😀 bus AP k hair both jaldi white ho gia ha. Sorry sir agar Bora Laga to
Respected sir, it's requested to put in your red room debate also a topic on US china strategic competition and it's influence on Pakistan in aspect of different dimensions .
Dr sab please raise your voice about a very critical and burning issue of the privatization of government schools and a blind and vague screening test of school teachers Sir I am a school teacher but sir last 6 nights l can't sleep because I serve government over 15 year but now provincial education minister of Punjab threatening us very badly I seriously thought to commit suicide every night I have three children in case of my death their financial future maybe saved Otherwise I am a patient of diabetes and can't afford my medicine and their educational expen So please 😢 your voice for our community And please don't mention my name so that I am be saved from anger of my high-ups I'm writing you in comments because no other way to contact you thanks A lot sir
Don't Panic life is precious. In Pakistan 50℅ population is living below poverty line so be thankful to Allah for government job In case ( which is near to impossible) you are fired from job Still you are ahead of many You can easily get a Teaching job in private school/College Ups and downs are part of life. Don't take stress of our family/ Children if they are capable they will achieve their objectives if they are not than pampering cannot help them
The Left in Pakistan is striving to regain its footing, grappling with challenges around ideological ambiguity and political unity. As discussed in today's podcast, amidst this complexity, left-leaning groups and young progressive activists across the provinces are working to reconnect with the public, aiming to return to grassroots, people-centered politics. After the near-hegemony of socialist ideology in the 1970s, we're now witnessing a resurgence of similar energy, re-emerging in the public sphere. The insights shared today offered a valuable perspective on the potential revival of the Left in Pakistan-Im especially impressed by the caliber of speakers featured in the Red Room series. Kudos to the entire team for this excellent work in advancing Left’s vision. remain hopeful for the journey ahead. 🌹
Plz answer sir this question i want to know if zizek is against postmodernism why his philosphy is primarly based on lacanain psycoanylsis .lacan who is postmodern then why zizek work is based on lacan
Since both of you were talking to the grandson of ZAB you glorified his "legacy" but when i listened to your previous pod where PTI's politics was discussed, you were criticizing ZAB. It did feel like hypocrisy, to me. ZAB junior,in his own capacity and personality is a wonderful person. His vision for environment is far far better than any responsible minister of relevance.
We are not metaphysicians who can only say good or bad things about periods of history. We are people who can appreciate certain aspects of Bhutto's rule while criticising other aspects.
He is grandson of Bhutto. Whereas Bilawal is not from Bhutto clan. In fact Bilawal is from Zardari clan. I don’t know why he never feel proud of his father side.
Jr is nothing like his grandfather, his aunt or for that matter his father , their narrative was different than their actions.. Zulfiqar was a tyrant, benezair stood quiet when Zardari was looting, his father hijacked an airplane, Jr is a people person he is an amazing human.. Out of this whole family he is the one.. Bilawal Zardari should learn something from him.. Bilawal is another example of this corrupt polititics.
Dear erudites! Everyone loves capital accumulation even in village based MNCs or TNCs, but they hate land accumulation by Wadheras and Feudals. When they raise hue & cry for "employment" it's not necessarily free independent autonomous owner-ooeratirship self employment but simplistically wage employment and salary employment preferably in private corporate sector whose Mantra is capital accumulation. So, it's loved. Even British East India Company located in India had 99.999% EMPLOYEES who were Indians and Indians just loved to be EMPLOYEES and loved to participate in political suppression and Jalianwala Bagh massacre with elan or ignorance. Anyway it was part of capitalist accumulation process. We the IDIOTS just love capital just as estranged capital loves to be with brainless mad people. 😃. Nade for each other! But why anthema against Land Accumulation? Isn't every capitalist project in world history based on the principle of so-called primitive accumulation of capital in the early stages of capitalism since 16th Century and it continues ditto as such in 2024? Land is capital. Capital loves land as commodity. Land mafias are common in capitalism. Calitalism is sophisticated Feudalism.
While its a great opportunity to witness a debate where all three speakers succumb to the same socialist narrative without any dissection but i really applaud the effort by the gentlemen to provide us with the Leftist narrative. However i believe that concurrently there are some gross inadequecies which are felt and some factual errors which are presented unintentionally (i would presume). To begin with:- 1. Construction of Tarbela dam directly never resulted in drought in Pakistan. Occurence of drought is a result of multitude of factors inclusive of deforestation, land degradation, population growth, climate change etc. 2. Mao Zedong was responsible for the deaths of millions of people and his policies resulted in gross human rights violations. The Great Leap Forward, Cultural Revolution and his tendency to suppress any dissent were all akin to criminal neglidence. I wonder how can your guest be so naive to even wear a monogram of Mao Zedong. 3. Your entire Korean argument raises a lot of questions. The NATO nexus which fought in Korea was a result of deliberate North Korean invasion supported by the Chinese. Just for perspective, look where both Countries stand today (North and South Korea) in terms of their economic clout, diplomatic standing and civic rights. 4. I appreciate your fervour for broader Middle East issues but there are some facts which we must not ignore. Foremost amongst is that Hassan Nasrullah was no martyr. From being complicit in the assasination of former Lebanese PM, Rafiq Hariri to drug trafficking involvement, Hassan Nasrullah can be anything other than a martyr. Not to mention his role in crushing Syrian uprising. We all are aware of Zionist regime genocidal actions. But lets understand that it is easier to decide between right and wrong. A person with absolutely no wisdom like me can also do that. However, a leader's task is to navigate his country in turmoil, amid hostile geopolitical forces and charter the best course of actions for his people. Sadly, the Arab leadership in general and specifically Hamas and Hezbollah's leadership displayed a lacklustre show in this regard. I hope i am able to convey. Intentions are not to offend anyone. Thanks
Is ZA Bhutto Jr. Socialist and Atheist? Do a largely fundamentalist population call him Kafir or whatever or such like terms? Is he accepted as such. Doing rescues in natural calamity is a separate thing. As Muslim?
Isase pahle wale bahut Dil Chahta hai yah mujhe thoda sa Boris Laga hai kyunki vah bahut Punjabi mein baat nahin kar raha tha English mein baat karta hun itni samajh Nahin a rahi thi
ذوالفقار علی بھٹو جونئیر کا ماحولیاتی تبدیلی جیسے حساس مسئلے کے بارے میں آگاہ ہونا اور عملی طور پر فعال ہونا۔ سیاسی فکر کے لحاظ سے غریب محور ہونا۔ ایک بہت امید افزا لیڈرشپ دیکھتا ہوں مگر پاکستانی سیاست سے دور رہنے کا مشورہ دوں گا۔ اتنی گندی سیاست میں اتنے معصوم لوگوں کو نہیں آنا چاہئیے۔
Why lands are not distributed to poor villagers? Btw why poor dont kill rich and take back what is rightfully theirs. How Islam became religion of oppression?
If there's no Urban Land Ceiling then why should there be Ceiling on Feudal Agricultural Land? No logic. It's the same in every country. Let's be anything but not hypocrites.
@ Because Cities don't have that absolute poverty like villages have/has. There is no Slavery/ Bonded Labour in cities. Yes Factory owners too should provide good salaries to workers. Villages in East Punjab are living good life as they own those small plots of land but in Pakistan? Most of Villagers dont own Land. Even a Tea Stall owner in city has better life than a villager who is forced to pay to Chowdhary. Look Indian Farmers dont have to pay for big Chowdharies but still farmers are committing suicides in Whole of India so what Pakistani Farmers would be doing? Only they know.
@@KenkalsiTowards the end of your reply you caught yourself trapped by your own argument. Land owning petty farmers committing suic*d*s but landless peasants in Pakistan living relatively free.
@@19665061 Yes, i know what i was writing so you are telling that farmers who don't own lands are happy? And why One family is owning whole villages? Its same as South African Apartheid. Anyway You should sell your land on yearly installments if you don't want to give land to real ppl who are real workers.
Brilliant interview. We hosted him in Chicago last year, he is such a humble soul, comes across a genuine person. Pakistan, and Sindh in particular, needs a leader like him.
The respect and time they are giving to their guest is applaudable. Very insightful programme
So much love for you Dr Taimur&Dr Ammar for bringing our hero Zulfiii❤
A big service you gentlemen are doing by sharing such great content. Hope the youth follows.
Thank You so very much Taimur for this interview. ..
Great and historical interview of JnR ZA Bhutto sb
Mesmerising. A treat to watch .
Excellent talk. I also seek for such kind of unity. Diversity is our real wealth just to unite it.
Such a great personality, my childhood was all about slogan of anti feudal by Altaf Hussain.
Great man.
His views are excellent and he has a great vision for the regional land. Also he is very misunderstood in masses.
Just wow. It felt so good listening to JZAB. Indeed, he is a hope for the poor people of not only Sindh but also of all Pakistan.
Thanks to red room for inviting him.
Lovely, brilliant interview ❤
We are proud of him.
Great interview and good job inviting him .❤
Zulfiqar Ali Bhuto J kitni achi baten krte hn inko invite krte raha kren dilun ko jorhne wale log kitne piyare hote hn
Tamam behtareen good work Baba zulfikar Ali Bhutto ❤🐬🇯🇴✌️
This was amazing. Thank you
Zaberdast interview hai shandar koshish hai international ism socialism he hai aur Trotsky ism he hai
First viewer ❤ great respect laal sir❤
♥️ loved the way he explained that flood. I witnessed it live and could totally resonate with what he is saying
Well-done zulfiqar, we all are united, just need to identify and convense to all that we are Indusians.
I loved when he said “ people knows each other personhood”
A much needed conversation.
بہت خوشی ہوئی ذولفقار علی بھٹو جونیئر کو خوبصورت اردو میں بات کرتا دیکھ کر ، 👋
My good wishes to you one day you will achieve your goals, Comrade!
Brave young man who is future of Pakistan.
He is promoter of LGBTQ. How can he be future of Pakistan.you can Google it
Highly informative.
Jazakallah!
Very impressive interview ❤ with ZAB
You guys never disappoint
The guy reveals his brains finally. The real ones should be in their place. But the challenge would emmensely tough because of the other side; who are Islamists beyond his personal rivalries.
You guys forgot bhutto started with progressive ideas and after coming to power within 3 years coming to power he changed also with the time and changed the way he wanted to govern he started listening to religious groups and change the original ppp agenda don't blame benazir.
Mashallah AP k sessions both informative ha.
Meri family b AP ka program bohat dekhti ha and included me ma b bachpan sa AP ki story PTV per dekhta tha.lakin ab internet mobile per convert ho gia.
Mashallah may Allah bless you always. One more thing 😀 bus AP k hair both jaldi white ho gia ha. Sorry sir agar Bora Laga to
Come forward there is more space for you people Comrades.❤
all three should have been on the screen at the same time - just my suggestion.
Alhumdullillah , he's quite wise , I'm impressed with his informations 🎉
Great Sir g
He is great ❤
Appreciate Tamour and Ammar..
A bit longer but worth listening. ZAB Jr has a spark which must be rekindled. ---Rasheed Khalid
Supper program
Excellent interview.He is miles ahead of Bilawal in political thought and maturity.I just hope he is taking care of his personal security.
Great person ❤❤
اللہ ذوالفقار کو شر شیطان ، شر طال بان اور شر زرداران سے محفوظ رکھے آمین
Ameen
He is gay@@AhmedKalwar-tl4nh
Real peoples real ideology
He is the best personality in the new generation of bhuto khandan ❤
Brilliant
Respected sir, it's requested to put in your red room debate also a topic on US china strategic competition and it's influence on Pakistan in aspect of different dimensions .
❤ Pakistan ki leadership ki lea junior zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Bhtar ha and Chairperson pppsb Ghinwa Bhutto ki ya takat ha or Pakistan ki bhi takat ha ❤❤
Thanks Tamour sb , you took a fragrance of real blood…… جب لال لال لہرائے گا ❤
Left was killed and PPP change its idelogical base because Soviet Union was collapsed. Same hapened in India and Bangladesh.
Zulfiqaar seems very humble on various occasion
Jan aur tumour bout acha kaam kia hai aap nay mubaruk hu
But we cannot distribute the water to the areas far from river if we don't build dams, then we have to stick near to the river only.
He is 💯 percent right
That’s not PPPP
IT IS ZARDAREE LEAGUE
He is welcomed to social libral n democratic politics
i dont get you
ZABJ is a fine brain we have.
Good
First viewer sir
Junior Bhutto Is Son Of Soil . He Is Well Aware From Geography And Political Situation Of His Country
Let him be ebviormemtal activist don't pull him in politics, leave him alone so his life should be spared😢
❤
Dr sab please raise your voice about a very critical and burning issue of the privatization of government schools and a blind and vague screening test of school teachers
Sir I am a school teacher but sir last 6 nights l can't sleep because I serve government over 15 year but now provincial education minister of Punjab threatening us very badly
I seriously thought to commit suicide every night
I have three children in case of my death their financial future maybe saved
Otherwise I am a patient of diabetes and can't afford my medicine and their educational expen
So please 😢 your voice for our community
And please don't mention my name so that I am be saved from anger of my high-ups
I'm writing you in comments because no other way to contact you thanks A lot sir
Don't Panic life is precious. In Pakistan 50℅ population is living below poverty line so be thankful to Allah for government job
In case ( which is near to impossible) you are fired from job Still you are ahead of many You can easily get a Teaching job in private school/College
Ups and downs are part of life. Don't take stress of our family/ Children if they are capable they will achieve their objectives if they are not than pampering cannot help them
Didnt his father moves towards arms struggle against state of Pakistan!
Yeah! He made a militant group Al-Zulfikar to avenge his father.
43:38 please don't forget Yemen
There's a great book on Indus and Pakistan, Empires of the Indus by Alice Albinia.
For heaven sake don't bring him in pakistan politics the family sacrificed too much for this country, let him be alive.
World famous leader zulifqar Ali Bhutto junior ❤
Our hero Junior Z.a Bhutto ❤
he is a great leader of sndh and pakistan
The Left in Pakistan is striving to regain its footing, grappling with challenges around ideological ambiguity and political unity. As discussed in today's podcast, amidst this complexity, left-leaning groups and young progressive activists across the provinces are working to reconnect with the public, aiming to return to grassroots, people-centered politics. After the near-hegemony of socialist ideology in the 1970s, we're now witnessing a resurgence of similar energy, re-emerging in the public sphere. The insights shared today offered a valuable perspective on the potential revival of the Left in Pakistan-Im especially impressed by the caliber of speakers featured in the Red Room series. Kudos to the entire team for this excellent work in advancing Left’s vision. remain hopeful for the journey ahead. 🌹
Plz answer sir this question i want to know if zizek is against postmodernism why his philosphy is primarly based on lacanain psycoanylsis .lacan who is postmodern then why zizek work is based on lacan
Since both of you were talking to the grandson of ZAB you glorified his "legacy" but when i listened to your previous pod where PTI's politics was discussed, you were criticizing ZAB. It did feel like hypocrisy, to me.
ZAB junior,in his own capacity and personality is a wonderful person. His vision for environment is far far better than any responsible minister of relevance.
We are not metaphysicians who can only say good or bad things about periods of history. We are people who can appreciate certain aspects of Bhutto's rule while criticising other aspects.
دریائے سندھ کشمیریوں کا بھی ھے۔۔۔۔
bilkul..balkay aap esa keh saktay hain k darya e Sindh Kashmir se peda hota hay...
He is grandson of Bhutto. Whereas Bilawal is not from Bhutto clan. In fact Bilawal is from Zardari clan. I don’t know why he never feel proud of his father side.
How to resolve this conflict or understand? : PDM wants Xi Ping. ZABhutto wants Mao.
I'm too Mao fan 😊
Dr. Taimur you are very intelligent person but why you don't disagree with people where you have to.
@@farhanpathan2976 I guess I’m generally a polite person.
Sir plz change the name of program "Red room" . It has some other bad connotation. Plz consider it.
Jr is nothing like his grandfather, his aunt or for that matter his father , their narrative was different than their actions.. Zulfiqar was a tyrant, benezair stood quiet when Zardari was looting, his father hijacked an airplane, Jr is a people person he is an amazing human.. Out of this whole family he is the one.. Bilawal Zardari should learn something from him.. Bilawal is another example of this corrupt polititics.
Great well done. Indus Valley
Dear erudites! Everyone loves capital accumulation even in village based MNCs or TNCs, but they hate land accumulation by Wadheras and Feudals. When they raise hue & cry for "employment" it's not necessarily free independent autonomous owner-ooeratirship self employment but simplistically wage employment and salary employment preferably in private corporate sector whose Mantra is capital accumulation. So, it's loved. Even British East India Company located in India had 99.999% EMPLOYEES who were Indians and Indians just loved to be EMPLOYEES and loved to participate in political suppression and Jalianwala Bagh massacre with elan or ignorance. Anyway it was part of capitalist accumulation process. We the IDIOTS just love capital just as estranged capital loves to be with brainless mad people. 😃. Nade for each other! But why anthema against Land Accumulation? Isn't every capitalist project in world history based on the principle of so-called primitive accumulation of capital in the early stages of capitalism since 16th Century and it continues ditto as such in 2024? Land is capital. Capital loves land as commodity. Land mafias are common in capitalism. Calitalism is sophisticated Feudalism.
He should be our leader, either him or Fatima Bhutto. We don’t need Imran Khan, PPP, PML-N, or anyone else.
Did anyone notice Zulfiqar going from perfect Urdu to broken Urdu? 😅.
جئے اصلی بھٹو ❤
Is there still such a thing as Bhutto legacy? Zardaris have already hijacked his legacy. Good luck to this young man though
I wish he was straight, and joins PTI revolution, imagine the impact 🎉
Jr❤
While its a great opportunity to witness a debate where all three speakers succumb to the same socialist narrative without any dissection but i really applaud the effort by the gentlemen to provide us with the Leftist narrative. However i believe that concurrently there are some gross inadequecies which are felt and some factual errors which are presented unintentionally (i would presume). To begin with:-
1. Construction of Tarbela dam directly never resulted in drought in Pakistan. Occurence of drought is a result of multitude of factors inclusive of deforestation, land degradation, population growth, climate change etc.
2. Mao Zedong was responsible for the deaths of millions of people and his policies resulted in gross human rights violations. The Great Leap Forward, Cultural Revolution and his tendency to suppress any dissent were all akin to criminal neglidence. I wonder how can your guest be so naive to even wear a monogram of Mao Zedong.
3. Your entire Korean argument raises a lot of questions. The NATO nexus which fought in Korea was a result of deliberate North Korean invasion supported by the Chinese. Just for perspective, look where both Countries stand today (North and South Korea) in terms of their economic clout, diplomatic standing and civic rights.
4. I appreciate your fervour for broader Middle East issues but there are some facts which we must not ignore. Foremost amongst is that Hassan Nasrullah was no martyr. From being complicit in the assasination of former Lebanese PM, Rafiq Hariri to drug trafficking involvement, Hassan Nasrullah can be anything other than a martyr. Not to mention his role in crushing Syrian uprising. We all are aware of Zionist regime genocidal actions. But lets understand that it is easier to decide between right and wrong. A person with absolutely no wisdom like me can also do that. However, a leader's task is to navigate his country in turmoil,
amid hostile geopolitical forces and charter the best course of actions for his people. Sadly, the Arab leadership in general and specifically Hamas and Hezbollah's leadership displayed a lacklustre show in this regard.
I hope i am able to convey. Intentions are not to offend anyone. Thanks
Kuch Bat,to ha Z.A BHUTTO,men,.....
New party new faces
کاش بینظیر کی شادی ۔۔۔۔
Is ZA Bhutto Jr. Socialist and Atheist? Do a largely fundamentalist population call him Kafir or whatever or such like terms? Is he accepted as such. Doing rescues in natural calamity is a separate thing. As Muslim?
He is not an atheist nor has he claimed to be an atheist. Apnay pas say labels na lagao
Bilawal zardari is 0 in front of him.
Isase pahle wale bahut Dil Chahta hai yah mujhe thoda sa Boris Laga hai kyunki vah bahut Punjabi mein baat nahin kar raha tha English mein baat karta hun itni samajh Nahin a rahi thi
ذوالفقار علی بھٹو جونئیر کا ماحولیاتی تبدیلی جیسے حساس مسئلے کے بارے میں آگاہ ہونا اور عملی طور پر فعال ہونا۔ سیاسی فکر کے لحاظ سے غریب محور ہونا۔ ایک بہت امید افزا لیڈرشپ دیکھتا ہوں مگر پاکستانی سیاست سے دور رہنے کا مشورہ دوں گا۔ اتنی گندی سیاست میں اتنے معصوم لوگوں کو نہیں آنا چاہئیے۔
ZA Bhutto saheb! Room walls are green. Is it The Unconscious of dominant Islamic ethos and influence of Pakistan? 😅
wow! Not one but two stupid comments mohinder sb. Colours don’t have religions. Colours have existed well before religions
yaa bhi nawabi hai 🍩
Should we also stop killing animals because they also feel pain?
❤❤❤
Why lands are not distributed to poor villagers?
Btw why poor dont kill rich and take back what is rightfully theirs.
How Islam became religion of oppression?
If there's no Urban Land Ceiling then why should there be Ceiling on Feudal Agricultural Land? No logic. It's the same in every country. Let's be anything but not hypocrites.
@ Because Cities don't have that absolute poverty like villages have/has.
There is no Slavery/ Bonded Labour in cities.
Yes Factory owners too should provide good salaries to workers.
Villages in East Punjab are living good life as they own those small plots of land but in Pakistan? Most of Villagers dont own Land.
Even a Tea Stall owner in city has better life than a villager who is forced to pay to Chowdhary.
Look Indian Farmers dont have to pay for big Chowdharies but still farmers are committing suicides in Whole of India so what Pakistani Farmers would be doing? Only they know.
@@KenkalsiTowards the end of your reply you caught yourself trapped by your own argument. Land owning petty farmers committing suic*d*s but landless peasants in Pakistan living relatively free.
@@19665061 Yes, i know what i was writing so you are telling that farmers who don't own lands are happy?
And why One family is owning whole villages? Its same as South African Apartheid.
Anyway You should sell your land on yearly installments if you don't want to give land to real ppl who are real workers.